Did Crosby really just have a concussion?

Posted by: joeruth

Tagged in: Untagged 

joeruth

Don't misunderstand me.  He had a neurological problem for sure.  What I am wondering after listening to his symptoms is if he actually had a concussion or something else.  Let me explain.

Several years ago, a friend of mine was having problems with her shoulder due to a repetitive strain injury.  After getting a lot of regular doctor run around, she settled on going to someone who did deep tissue massage to get relief from her swelling and muscle weakness in her right arm.  At first, it went really well.  The strength came back and the swelling was just about gone.  Then rather suddenly it all came back and with a vengeance.   New symptoms appeared which sounded eerily reminiscent of Crosby's.  Trouble with motion while riding in a car.  Extreme sensitivity to noise and light.  It was all vey strange and bizarre.

She stopped the therapy and went to a trigger point person who was more specific about the treatment and did not do the deep tissue massage.  The symptoms faded and she is pretty much near normal now.  The working theory is that the massage therapist worked heavily on her neck and bruised it to the point that swelling was starting to affect the the top of the spinal cord or the base of the brain.  Nobody hit her with a baseball bat or dumped her down the steps or any other trauma like that.  

I don't know... I don't have the specific information or nor do I pretend to.  However, when I heard the Crosby talking about his symptoms, it was kind of eerie.  

Just wondering...

Comments (3)Add Comment
Toadsly
...
Toadsly, September 10, 2011 - 07:35 PM
You may be on to something, joeruth.
Jersey Joe
...
Jersey Joe, September 11, 2011 - 06:19 PM
8-9-10 months later and the kid still has headaches, this is just plain nuts thinking he should ever play the game again.

Try to remember the kind of september when Mike Webster was normal.

Google Chuck Finder's vast amount of work on head injuries.

You want to make gov. bigger, outlaw youth football and anything else that allows head contact.

Sid may have damaged his brain for life. one more hit could kill him or vegtablize him.

If you care about him, call for him to retire and be thankful for what he had and pray he has a future free of pain.
joeruth
...
joeruth, October 09, 2011 - 02:28 PM
I think there is a certain amount of ignorance about how these things go and as long as our doctors don't admit that, it is trouble. I think we don't really understand what the split of the duties between the top of the spinal cord vs the base of the brain actually are.

Crosby's problems were mostly perceptual. As my favorite opthamaologist keep saying.. you don't see with your eyes... you see with your brain. Something happens to the filtering mechanism and we don't really know where that is.

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy